Monday, August 06, 2012

Political Wolfsbane

I find that three simple words work to devastate virtually all radical political arguments. First, "Why?" When they tell you, "Prove it."

Most people's heads simply spin and they sputter and wander off. Through bitter experience I have learned that most have almost zero understanding of politics and never reasoned anything out at all, they just spouted off with or repeated whatever sounded like a good idea at the time. If actually asked to support their assertions, they have nothing. If they have any grace, they'll admit it.

A minority will take up the challenge, however, either because they actually know a little something about the subject matter or because they feel that their pride is on the line. This is when you spring the trap, and point out things like:
FBI figures show just 358 of the 8,775 murders by firearm in 2010 involved rifles of any type. By comparison, 745 people were beaten to death with only hands that year, but no one has called for outlawing fists.
Or perhaps ask why 12 deaths by firearm is a horrible event requiring drastic action, but 14 deaths by truck is a nonevent, unworthy of consideration.

At the very least, bringing facts, data, and logic into play will improve a political process dominated by juvenile tribalism and manipulative soundbites.



Sunday, August 05, 2012

Political News of the Day

The Daily Mail is reporting that a twelve year old girl has conducted genealogical research and proven that all but one of the presidents of the US (the one being Martin van Buren) are descendants of King John I. "They all have the trait of wanting power," d’Avignon [the girl] said.

That's incredible.

Incredibly fucking stupid, that is. For one thing, royal lines tend to be well-monitored. The scions of royal families know of their histories, and so does everyone else. They also tend to dwindle as progeny die in coups, wars, revolutions, and intrigues. I'm confident that some herald, somewhere, has tracked down the Plantagenet line to its final points.

Oh. Look. "When Henry VII executed Edward, the Earl of Warwick in 1499, the House of Plantagenet went extinct in the legitimate male line. Margaret Pole, the Earl of Warwick's sister and last legitimate Plantagenet, was executed for treason by Henry VIII in 1541. Edward IV's illegitimate son Arthur Plantagenet, 1st Viscount Lisle was a member of Henry VIII's court until he was arrested and charged with treason in 1540. He was cleared of the treason charges but just before he was to be released from the Tower of London in 1542 he suffered a heart attack and died."

Huh.

For another, that any class of people in a country as varied as the United States spread over more than two centuries shares any measurable common ancestor is unbelievable. Even the German Eisenhower? The Dutch Roosevelts? The Kenyan Obama? The Irish Kennedy? Somehow, they're all descended from English royalty? The SAME king? Please.

Third, was there some sort of sorcerous force that conspired to ensure that only these lost sons of royalty won their elections and obtained their offices? Was it divine providence that had Franklin Roosevelt, descendant of King John, select Harry Truman, descendant of King John (one of the few presidents to have not graduated college before serving in office, chosen to be a non-threatening, working class appeal to Middle America), for his Vice President? Did fate conspire to have frontier-dwelling-but-secretly-Plantagenet-royalty Lincoln select the Scotch-Irish-but-secretly-Plantagenet-royalty Andrew Johnson as his VP, or was it because he was from Tennessee and represented a symbolic attempt to hold together the union, like the history books and primary documents say?

Fourth, there are real difficulties in tracing most American ancestors before the 18th century. Hardly a surprise, since literacy was not universal and people sort of appeared on the American continent in drips and drabs with spotty records, if any at all. Yet 43 of the 44 US Presidents can be traced with certainty to 12th century England? And, since the legitimate Plantagenet line was made extinct, these bloodlines were traced with certainty through royal bastards?

This sounds like an asinine conspiracy theory given a veneer of legitimacy; 'oh, a little girl has researched this, it must be true.' That anyone is taking this seriously in the absence of thorough, and I mean mountainous, proof makes me want to weep.

Once more...

I have a tendency to use Facebook (which I generally loathe) like a blog, linking the outrage or inspiration of the day with accompanying commentary. I think this drives other people crazy, especially the ones for whom FB is just a method of sharing cat pictures and gossip.

Basically, it's like I'm blogging to a captive audience. Enter A Clockwork Orange.

Ergo, I'm going to make an effort to channel all of my rants, etc. here, instead. I'll get more space and the ability to give multiple links, images, and so on without having to dip my heel into the horrible black pool of social media. And anyone who actually likes such things can come by and view it at their leisure.

Friday, October 01, 2010

Another Shocker: Yasser Arafat was a terrorist

This... this is news? Really?

It's amazing to see the MSM getting around to noticing things that people in the business have known for, oh, ever. I bet these people would be amazed to learn that the Second Intifada was deliberately launched by Arafat as well, and not a spontaneous uprising because an old man visited a shrine after all. But don't take my word for it.

Shocker: Obama planning to lose Afghanistan

Such is the exegesis from Woodward's new book. For the record, I called this more than a year ago. Evidence of such is in a blog comment though, so I'll have to go find it.

Edit: Here is a reference from June, but it's not the first one I made. I'll post the other one if I find it.

Edit 2: Found it.  Though apparently it was in early December, so not quite a year ago yet.

Once more unto the breach...

I can't believe this thing is still here. Pleased, though. Lately, I've been abusing my Facebook feed as a blog. I figure that I may as well take the plunge back into blogging. I spend so much time in front of a computer these days anyway.

Friday, August 29, 2008

Difference Between Republicans and Democrats

At the Democratic National Convention in Denver, the crowds chanted, "O-ba-ma, O-ba-ma, O-ba-ma!"

At the rally to present McCain's VP choice, Sarah Palin, the crowds chanted, "U-S-A, U-S-A, U-S-A."

A starker and more genuine chasm I haven't seen yet in this race.

Thursday, August 14, 2008

More of the Same

A Swede throws down his medal, pissed that a judge's decision awarded an opponent the gold. Although the article is very light on the details of the confrontation, a coach is quoted as saying, "It's all politics."

Also, the thing about the underage Chinese gymnasts has gained traction. Naturally, the Chinese have no idea what anyone's talking about.

Wednesday, August 13, 2008

'Obamacans' a Myth

This shouldn't be a surprise to anyone. In fact, it's a surprise to me to see that anyone bought into the myth in the first place.

As we speak/type/read, the Obama camp is holding a conference call with reporters to unveil "Republicans for Obama," a branch of its operation designed to show that "Republicans are coming together in support of Senator Obama to bring change to Washington." That claim was verifiable during the early Democratic primaries, when Republicans willing to crossover and vote in the Democratic contests typically backed Obama over Hillary Clinton by overwhelming margins. Which is why Obama began telling his Obamacan tale in the first place.
Hatred for Hillary Clinton (always strong on the Right) does not equal love of Obama. (also remember that the Obama we know now is not the Obama we thought we knew... hah!) In many states, people can vote in whatever primary they want. Voting against the Clintonion Doom Harpy in a primary does not equate a vote for Obama in the general.

If Republicans were asked to choose between Russia and Iran, and they choose Russia, it doesn't mean that Russia is their favorite country.

If 2nd graders have to choose between Vanilla and Chocolate, it doesn't mean that their favorite isn't Caramel Sundae Crunch.

It's elementary.

The Olympics as a Political Event

My wife loves the Summer Olympics. She's watched it every 4 years since she was able to hold her head level at a television screen, with the sole exception of the 2004 Athens games. (I was away with the military at the time, and she was working 60 hours a week) To her, they are a great and inspiring sporting event. Quality entertainment.

She was watching before I was and commented when I joined her at how perfect the Chinese synchronized swim team was and how well the Chinese in general were performing. I observed that of course they are; they're from a communistic police state that forces some of their people to do nothing but train for these kinds of events. I'm sure they're quite good at making synchronized athletes to support their politics.

She's used to me making cynical observations like this, and so simply let me have my little fantasy and went on with watching women's gymnastics. I know this tactic, however, and continued my assault on her worldview.

She kind of rolled her eyes as I continued to explain that the Olympics are not a sporting event. Not anymore. Rather, they are a political event. An arena where nations contest against one another not for love of the sports or competitions, but as a contest for prestige for one's people, ideology, and way of life, and it had been so since the 30's when Jesse Owens trounced the Master Race (there's a pun in there, somewhere) in Berlin.

Then one of the commentators observed that such and such Chinese gymnast had been relegated to a gymnastics training camp at the age of 3, with one parental visit allowed per year. When she once asked to be sent home because she didn't want to do it anymore, she was denied. Sinner-wife's ears perked up. This was news to her. Suddenly, I didn't sound so crazy and John Birch Society-ish.

Shortly thereafter, Bella Karolyi (who was acting as a guest commentator for the channel... NBC? I forget, and don't care) made the casual observation when talking about the Chinese's performance that 14 and 15 year olds are typically at the top of their game during these kinds of performances because they have no fear. His 'minder' in the studio said that he had caught Bella in a mistake, because the minimum age for girl's gymnastics was 16. Bella snorted and said that half the Chinese team was under age. But their Chinese government issued passports used as identification said 16, so what can you do? (which is totally friggin' obvious if you look at them and compare them to the other teams' girls)

'Wait,' says the Sinner-wife. 'The Chinese government is supposedly lying to the world just so its chosen athletes can compete?'

'What part of communistic police state and competitive political event is unclear?'

'Hmm,' says she.

That's not even counting Iranians who refuse to compete against Israelis, and other such political crap leaking into the event.

And then this morning I see this. Apparently, the Georgians stacked their volleyball team with foreign nationals (a pair of Brazilians).

Said one of the Russians,
"They don't even know who the Georgian President is, how can you call them Georgians? They are Brazilians and that is who we played against today," Shiryaeva said.

Santanna admitted she had only been to Georgia twice in her life and still lived in Brazil, but said she still felt Georgian because the President had personally given her citizenship.
Even democratic states see the Olympics as a political arena and will play a little dirty in order to win.

It's a little sad to see someone's image of the Olympics as a great, incorruptible tradition of fellowship and sport crumble to dust. But such is the world we live in.